Category Archives: State Action Immunity

Fourth Circuit Affirms that Maryland Liquor Regulation is Anticompetitive

In TFWS Inc. v. Peter Franchot et al., 4th Circuit Court of Appeals refused to reverse its earlier decision that Maryland’s liquor and wine regulations involving 1) post-and-hold pricing system, which governs how and when liquor wholesalers may charge their prices; and 2) a volume discount ban, which prevents wholesalers from offering lower prices to […]

Second Circuit Revives Hospital Antitrust Case Reversing State Action Based Summary Judgment

In Lafaro v. New York Cardiothoracic Group PLLC, Second Circuit Court of Appeals vacated a lower court’s ruling of summary judgment for a surgeon and his practice – defendants in an antitrust case over access to operating rooms at state-run Westchester Medical Center in New York – finding that although the state-run hospital as a […]

Antitrust Attack on Concert Promotion Agreement Survives Motion to Dismiss

A competing arena has attacked an agreement between concert promoter Live Nation and the Grand Rapids/Kent County Convention Authority that entitles 1) Live Nation to 1/3 of the revenue from non-Live Nation events at Convention Authority venues, and 2) the Convention Authority 1/3 of Live Nation’s revenue at Live Nation events scheduled at competing venues.  The owner […]